Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel
9900 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN, 46038
Questions to Ask When You Call
You're not expected to know this. These questions help you compare and avoid surprises.
“Can I see your General Price List?”
Federal law (FTC Funeral Rule) requires them to give you itemized pricing. You have every right to ask.
“Do you accept insurance assignment?”
This means they bill the insurance company directly. You don't pay thousands upfront and wait to be reimbursed.
“What's included vs. what's extra?”
Packages may not include everything. Ask about the casket, embalming, transportation, facility fees, and death certificate copies.
Know Your Rights
The FTC Funeral Rule protects you. Every funeral home must provide an itemized General Price List if you ask — in person or over the phone. You are never required to buy a package and can choose services individually. You also have the right to use a casket purchased elsewhere.
Payment & Financial Options
Average in Indiana
$2,246 – $7,063
Source: NFDA 2023 · Direct cremation to traditional burial
If they had life insurance, it can cover this
Funerals in this area run $2,246–$7,063. If your loved one had a life insurance policy, the benefit can cover these costs — and we'll file the claim and handle the carrier for you, even without the policy number. $0 upfront, and nothing if it doesn't pay out.
What Families Say
“Shirley Brothers recently handled the services for my wife. It was a difficult time but the staff were superb in all of their support. I especially want to thank Laura the funeral director. Thanks to her the services went smoothly. My family and I will call on them again when my time comes.”
— Robert Williams
“Jessica helped me complete my advanced planning project. She cared about my wishes and needs over trying to sell me services and products. I appreciated that. She offered information and options. She answered all my questions. She made a discussion I didn't want to have, easy and pleasant.”
— Alice Sobotka
“The Shirley Brothers team did an outstanding job during a very difficult time. My father's passing was not planned and swift; therefore, I made a first call to Jim Shirley early in the morning and from that point forward, I had nothing to worry about. They immediately onboarded my father and setup a convenient time for me to come in to their Fishers location to meet with Alan and work out the details. Alan was very professional, while being down to earth and made me feel comfortable and relaxed. There was absolutely no pressure for any services, he tactfully captured my father's wishes and handled all the rest. The people at Shirley Brothers are amazingly caring and their facilities and services are top-notch with very competitive pricing. I highly recommend partnering with this provider if you're pre-planning or taking care of a loved one.”
— Warren Back
We can help with what comes next.
We file the life insurance claim and recover unclaimed property — the payout can help cover costs like these. $0 upfront.
Are you Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel?
Claim your free listing to receive the families we connect you with, show your services and pricing, and partner with MedaSynq — at no cost.
Claim your free listing